Tony's N.Y. Pizza Menu

Tony’s N.Y. Pizza on Marco Island delivers an authentic New York-style experience with a menu that truly stands out. Their Meat Lovers Pizza boasts a perfect balance of savory meats atop a thin, crisp crust, avoiding the typical grease that often weighs down the flavors. The Stromboli and Calzone Cheese offer hearty, satisfying options, each packed with rich, melted cheese and traditional Italian fillings. Freshness and flavor extend beyond the pizzas; the Antipasto and Athens salads bring vibrant greens, olives, and cured meats, dressed perfectly with house vinaigrette. The variety of sauces—from tangy BBQ to creamy blue cheese—enhance every bite, catering to diverse tastes. Customers like Nicole praise the garlic knots for their ideal texture, while others rave about the crisp crust and generous cheese portions. With a wine selection featuring Merlot and Chardonnay, Tony’s strikes a harmonious chord between classic pizzeria fare and thoughtful, quality ingredients, making each visit memorable and delicious.