Tony's N.Y. Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Marco Island, Tony's N.Y. Pizza is a true slice of authentic New York-style pizza that has quickly become a beloved local gem. Specializing in classic pizza flavors with a perfect thin and crisp crust, this cozy pizzeria offers an inviting atmosphere that transports you straight to the bustling streets of Manhattan. Tony’s charm is evident in its red and white checkered tablecloths and nostalgic New York memorabilia adorning the walls—details that perfectly complement the delicious experience awaiting you.

The menu at Tony’s N.Y. Pizza is a celebration of iconic Italian-American favorites. Meat lovers will find pure satisfaction in their signature Meat Lovers Pizza, which strikes the ideal balance between a savory, robust sauce and layers of melting, gooey cheese—never too greasy, as several delighted guests have noted. For those craving variety, the Stromboli and Calzone Cheese are standout items. The Cheese Calzone — stuffed with mozzarella, ricotta, romano cheese, garlic, and fresh herbs — offers a rich, comforting bite, while the Stromboli, loaded generously with sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and mozzarella, tastes like a hearty, flavor-packed adventure wrapped in golden dough.

Complement your meal with one of Tony’s fresh and vibrant side salads. Whether it’s the Side Athens Salad bursting with crisp romaine, ripe tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta, and a subtle zing of banana peppers, or the classic Side Caesar Salad with its perfectly crunchy croutons and shaved romano cheese, every bite enhances your dining experience. Fans of hearty sides will appreciate the tender meatballs served with marinara sauce and a sprinkle of romano—pure soul food in every forkful.

The beverage selection keeps things refreshingly simple with a variety of fountain sodas and bottled favorites, including Coca-Cola options and San Pellegrino for a touch of sparkle.

What truly sets Tony’s apart is the unanimous praise from visitors who consistently highlight the perfection of their pizzas. Nicole raves about the garlic knots with their impeccable texture and the BBQ & milk wings that rank among the best she’s ever tasted. Candace, a visitor from Chicago, declares this place “by far, the BEST pizza on the island” thanks to its crisp, thin crust and authentic taste that rivals any New York pizzeria. Meanwhile, long-time regular TJ Ferguson emphasizes the generous cheese portions paired with equally stellar sauce and crust, calling it the top pizza spot on Marco Island—sometimes even three days in a row! Caroline admires the variety, including gluten-free options that retain an impressively crispy crust, while Anne appreciates the generous portions and reasonable prices that make dining in a vibrant, lively atmosphere a joyous occasion.

If you find yourself craving a pie that perfectly balances rich, savory flavors with a light yet satisfyingly crispy base, Tony’s N.Y. Pizza is your go-to destination on Marco Island. Its genuine New York spirit, friendly vibe, and consistently stellar food create an experience that not only satisfies hunger but leaves you with a warm, lasting impression of quality and care.

Visit Tony’s N.Y. Pizza at 145 S Barfield Dr or give them a call at +1 239-970-0027 to place your order. Whether dining in, picking up, or having your favorite slice delivered, Tony’s promises a taste of New York that’s simply unforgettable.